Keeping Up With the Joneses: A Case Study in What Peer Spending Really Costs
Nearly one in three Americans (32%) say they feel financial pressure to keep up with someone, and 51% admit they’ve overspent to impress another person, according to a 2024 LendingTree survey of 1,964 U.S. consumers. That’s what keeping up with the Joneses looks like now: less a jealous glance at the neighbor’s new car, more a steady drip of small, visible purchases that seem perfectly reasonable one at a time. In this case study you’ll see how peer-driven spending builds up in a realistic budget, what three major economic studies say about how strong the effect is, and a seven-step plan to cut the cost without cutting yourself off from friends.
The Case: A $72,000 Salary and a Budget That Kept Leaking
Meet Maya. She’s a composite, not a real person, but her numbers will look familiar. She earns $72,000 a year, has no credit card debt, contributes enough to her 401(k) to get the match, and says her budget “basically works.” Still, her savings account barely grew this year, and she can’t name a single big purchase that explains why.
When she lines up twelve months of card statements against what she planned to spend, the gap isn’t one splurge. It’s a group of purchases with one thing in common: each one was prompted by what someone around her was doing.
| Peer-prompted spending | Trigger | Extra per month |
|---|---|---|
| Restaurant upgrades (picked by the group) | Friends’ standing dinner moved to a pricier spot | $120 |
| Phone financed on a 24-month plan | Two coworkers upgraded the same week | $45 |
| Group trip, spread over the year | “Everyone’s going” | $110 |
| Fitness studio vs. her old gym | Instagram posts from friends | $85 |
| Matching gifts at birthdays and holidays | Reciprocating what others spent | $50 |
| Total | $410 ($4,920/yr) |
None of these line items is irresponsible on its own. That’s exactly why the pattern is hard to see. The fitness studio is “health.” The trip is “experiences over things.” The gifts are “being a good friend.” Every purchase comes with a justification, and every justification is borrowed from the people around her.
Here’s the part that should get your attention. If Maya redirected that $4,920 a year into a diversified index fund and earned a hypothetical 7% average annual return, the money would grow to about $67,977 after 10 years, $201,698 after 20 years, and $464,747 after 30 years. Those figures are illustrations, not promises, since real returns vary year to year. But they show the real price of keeping up with the Joneses: it isn’t the $45 phone payment, it’s the compounding you give up.
What the Research Says About Keeping Up With the Joneses
It’s tempting to file peer spending under “weak willpower.” Economists who have measured it see something more structural. Three studies are especially useful because they don’t rely on people describing their own motives. They watch what households actually do when the people around them get richer.
Neighbors of lottery winners borrow more and go bankrupt more
Sumit Agarwal, Vyacheslav Mikhed, and Barry Scholnick used Canadian lottery wins as a natural experiment, because a win is a random jump in one neighbor’s income. Their paper, published in the Review of Financial Studies in 2020, found that the dollar size of one neighbor’s lottery win increases later borrowing and bankruptcies among the other neighbors. The bankrupt neighbors had taken on more secured debt, the kind used for cars and homes, which are exactly the assets other people can see.
When the neighbor gets a BMW, you buy a car
The Dutch Postcode Lottery is an unusually clean test. Each week it picks a postal code (19 households on average) and gives prizes, including a new BMW, to participating households there. Peter Kuhn, Peter Kooreman, Adriaan Soetevent, and Arie Kapteyn found that neighbors’ winnings had social effects on two kinds of spending: cars and exterior home renovations. Both are about as visible as consumption gets. Their results were published in the American Economic Review in 2011.
Rising top incomes trickle down as spending, not wealth
Marianne Bertrand and Adair Morse looked at the broader picture in “Trickle-Down Consumption” (Review of Economics and Statistics, 2016). They estimated that middle-income households would have saved 2.6 to 3.2 percent more by the mid-2000s if top incomes had grown only at the median rate. The spending that responded most was on income-elastic, visible goods and services. Non-rich households exposed to higher top incomes also reported more financial stress, and higher top incomes predicted more personal bankruptcy filings.
| Study | What changed | What peers did |
|---|---|---|
| Agarwal, Mikhed & Scholnick (RFS, 2020) | A neighbor won the lottery | Borrowed more; bankruptcies rose with the size of the win |
| Kuhn, Kooreman, Soetevent & Kapteyn (AER, 2011) | Neighbors won cash and a BMW | Spent more on cars and exterior home renovations |
| Bertrand & Morse (REStat, 2016) | Top incomes in the area rose | Saved 2.6–3.2% less; more visible spending, more financial stress |
The common thread is visibility. People don’t try to keep up with a neighbor’s 401(k) balance, because they can’t see it. They keep up with the driveway, the renovation, the vacation photos. This is the social version of the Diderot effect, where one new purchase makes everything around it look like it needs an upgrade too.
Why Social Comparison Spending Hits Younger Earners Hardest
The old version of the Joneses lived on your street. The current version lives in your phone, and there are thousands of them. In the same LendingTree survey, 49% of Americans agreed that social media pressures them to spend money on things they don’t need. The generational split is steep:
| Generation | Feel pressure to keep up with someone |
|---|---|
| Gen Z | 62% |
| Millennials | 44% |
| Gen X | 25% |
| Baby boomers | 8% |
| All Americans | 32% |
The consequences aren’t trivial. Among people who overspent to impress someone, 56% said they had gone into debt because of it, and 63% regretted their most recent instance. The top reasons were impressing a date (30%), wanting to feel successful (29%), and reciprocating someone else’s generosity (23%). That last one is Maya’s gift line, and it may be the easiest kind of peer spending to defend and the hardest to stop.
The stakes are higher because many households don’t have much cushion. In the Federal Reserve’s 2024 Survey of Household Economics and Decisionmaking, 63% of adults said they would cover a hypothetical $400 emergency expense using only cash or its equivalent. That figure was unchanged from 2022 and 2023 and below the 68% peak in 2021. For the other 37%, money spent keeping up appearances comes straight out of the buffer that’s supposed to catch real problems.
Status spending also wears off fast. The glow from a nicer phone or a pricier gym fades within weeks, which is hedonic adaptation doing its job. The monthly payment doesn’t fade. That mismatch is why peer-driven costs tend to pile up instead of getting reversed.
I’ll admit I’m not immune to this. As a software engineer, I spent a stretch where it felt like everyone around me was upgrading something: mechanical keyboards, standing desks, the latest laptop the day it shipped. I wasn’t buying out of envy so much as a quiet sense that this was the normal setup for someone in my line of work. What finally cut through it was a small script I wrote to tag each transaction by whether I’d planned it or “saw it somewhere first.” The second category was a lot bigger than I expected, and seeing it as one number did more than any amount of willpower. I’m a DIY investor who puts most of my savings into index funds and tax-advantaged accounts, so turning that number into an automatic transfer was the obvious next step.
How to Stop Keeping Up With the Joneses: A 7-Step Plan
The goal isn’t to become the friend who never says yes. It’s to make peer-prompted spending a choice you make on purpose instead of a default. Here’s the plan Maya could follow, and you can too.
- Audit 90 days of spending for “borrowed” purchases. Go through your last three months of transactions and mark anything you bought mainly because someone you know (or follow) had it, did it, or suggested it. Don’t judge each item yet. You’re measuring the total, just like Maya’s $410 a month. Most people underestimate this number because each purchase feels individually justified.
- Separate visible from invisible spending. The research is consistent: peer effects concentrate on things other people can see, like cars, homes, clothes, trips, and restaurants. Put your marked items into “visible” and “private” columns. If most of the leak is visible, you’ve confirmed the social comparison pattern and know exactly where to set limits.
- Give social spending its own capped budget line. Banning social spending usually backfires. Instead, give it a named category with a monthly cap, for example $150 for “group plans and gifts.” When the dinner spot gets upgraded, you’re not deciding whether to be cheap. You’re just checking whether it fits this month’s line. A commitment device like a separate debit card for this category makes the cap automatic.
- Add a 72-hour rule for anything you saw on social media. If a purchase started with a post, a video, or a coworker’s recommendation, wait three days before buying. The urgency behind status purchases usually fades faster than the actual desire, and three days is often enough to tell which one you’re feeling.
- Prune your comparison feed. You can’t move away from the Joneses, but you can mute them. Unfollow or mute accounts that consistently make you feel behind, especially lifestyle influencers and brand accounts. With 49% of Americans saying social media pushes them toward unneeded spending, cutting down on triggers is one of the highest-leverage moves you can make.
- Script the friendly “no” and offer an alternative. Most peer spending happens in the moment, which is the worst time to make a money decision. Have a ready line: “I’m in for the next one, but this month’s tapped. Want to do a potluck instead?” Offering a lower-cost alternative keeps the relationship while changing the price tag. You’ll often find others were relieved someone said it first.
- Redirect the difference automatically, on payday. Whatever you free up, set it to move automatically into savings or investments the day your paycheck lands. That’s what turns $410 a month into the compounding numbers above. If you got a raise recently, this matters even more. Our take on lifestyle creep and raise allocation walks through how to split new income before your peers’ spending sets the default for you.
How much room does your budget have for social spending once the essentials are covered?
What Happens to Maya’s Budget After 90 Days
Suppose Maya runs the plan. She keeps the group trip, which she values, and puts it inside a $150 social line along with gifts. She goes back to her old gym and keeps one studio class a month as a treat. She swaps every other group dinner for a rotating potluck, which two friends happily take over. She leaves the phone payment alone because it’s a contract, but she decides not to upgrade again until the current one stops working.
The result: her peer-prompted spending drops from about $410 to around $200 a month. That frees up roughly $210 a month, or $2,520 a year, which goes straight into her Roth IRA by automatic transfer. Using the same hypothetical 7% return, that’s about $34,800 after 10 years. Her social life looks almost the same. Her balance sheet doesn’t.
The deeper change is that she’s no longer letting someone else’s lifestyle set her spending. That connects to other patterns covered in our money psychology guide: once you can name the bias, you can design around it instead of fighting it every day.
When Social Spending Is Worth It
Not all keeping-up spending is wasted. Shared experiences with people you care about can be some of the best uses of discretionary money, and turning down every invitation has real social costs. The question isn’t whether you spend money with and around other people. It’s whether you chose that spending or absorbed it from them.
A useful test: would you still want this if nobody else could see it or know about it? If yes, it’s probably your own preference. If the honest answer is “not really,” you’ve found the Joneses in your budget, and you now have a plan for showing them out.
Key Takeaways
- Keeping up with the Joneses is common: 32% of Americans feel pressure to keep up with someone, and 51% have overspent to impress someone (LendingTree, 2024).
- Peer-driven spending is measurable. Lottery studies show neighbors of winners borrow more, buy more cars, and file for bankruptcy more often.
- The effect concentrates on visible goods, such as cars, homes, trips, and restaurants, so that’s where to set limits.
- Small leaks add up: $410 a month invested at a hypothetical 7% return would be about $67,977 after 10 years.
- A capped social budget line, a 72-hour rule, a pruned feed, and automatic payday transfers work better than willpower.
Sources: LendingTree overspending survey (February 2024, n=1,964); Agarwal, Mikhed & Scholnick, “Peers’ Income and Financial Distress,” Review of Financial Studies 33(1), 2020; Kuhn, Kooreman, Soetevent & Kapteyn, “The Effects of Lottery Prizes on Winners and Their Neighbors,” American Economic Review 101(5), 2011; Bertrand & Morse, “Trickle-Down Consumption,” Review of Economics and Statistics 98(5), 2016; Federal Reserve, Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2024 (May 2025). Investment projections are hypothetical illustrations and not a guarantee of future returns.
Photo by Iuliia Pilipeichenko on
Unsplash