Regret Aversion Investing: A 7-Step Plan to Stop Second-Guessing Every Move
Investors who sold winners and held losers in a classic study of 10,000 brokerage accounts gave up roughly 3.4 percentage points of return over the following year — and a big reason they did it was to avoid the sting of admitting a mistake. That’s regret aversion investing in a nutshell: making portfolio decisions to dodge the feeling of being wrong rather than to maximize what you end up with. This guide walks you through who is most exposed, what to set up first, and a seven-step process to keep the fear of regret from steering your money.
Who This Regret Aversion Investing Guide Is For
Regret aversion is the tendency to avoid choices that could leave you feeling foolish later. Economists Graham Loomes and Robert Sugden formalized it as “regret theory” in a 1982 paper in The Economic Journal, arguing that people don’t just weigh outcomes — they weigh how an outcome will feel compared with the option they passed up. In investing, that produces two opposite failure modes: freezing (never acting, so you can’t be blamed) and herding (doing what everyone else does, so at least you’re wrong together).
You’ll get the most from this plan if any of these sound familiar:
- You have cash sitting on the sidelines “until the market pulls back,” and it’s been there for months.
- You hold a losing stock mainly because selling it would make the loss official.
- You check your portfolio after every headline and replay what you “should have” done.
- You bought something because it was popular, reasoning that if it fails, you won’t be the only one.
The cost isn’t abstract. Morningstar’s annual Mind the Gap study found that over the decade ending December 2024, the average dollar invested in U.S. mutual funds and ETFs earned about 7.0% a year, while the funds themselves returned about 8.2% — a 1.2-percentage-point annual gap, or roughly 15% of the funds’ total return. Morningstar attributes most of that shortfall to poorly timed purchases and sales, exactly the kind of moves regret aversion encourages.
Prerequisites Before You Start
The steps below work best if three things are already in place. Skipping them tends to turn every market dip into a new regret decision.
1. An emergency fund held outside your portfolio. If a job loss could force you to sell investments, every downturn feels like a personal threat. Keeping three to six months of expenses in cash removes that pressure.
2. A rough target allocation. You don’t need a perfect number. “80% stocks, 20% bonds” or “one target-date fund” is enough. The point is to have a reference you can compare against instead of your gut.
3. Ten minutes of honesty about your last three investment decisions. Write down what you did, why, and how you felt afterward. Most people discover a pattern — usually either chronic delay or chasing what’s already up.
The 7-Step Plan to Beat Regret Aversion in Investing
Step 1: Name the regret you’re actually avoiding
Regret comes in two flavors, and they push you in opposite directions. Psychologists Thomas Gilovich and Victoria Husted Medvec, writing in Psychological Review in 1995, found that people tend to feel more regret about actions in the short run but more about inactions over the long run. Investors overweight the short-run sting of a bad trade and underweight the slow-burning regret of never investing at all.
Before any decision, finish this sentence: “If this goes wrong, I’ll regret ______.” If the answer is “buying right before a drop,” you’re guarding against action regret. If it’s “missing the rally,” you’re guarding against inaction regret. Naming it makes it easier to see that you can’t eliminate regret — only choose which kind you’re more willing to risk.
Step 2: Compare the real cost of waiting
Regret aversion investing often shows up as parked cash. The feeling is “I’ll go in once things calm down.” The data are not kind to that plan. Vanguard’s 2023 research paper on cost averaging looked at rolling one-year periods from 1976 to 2022 for a 100% global-equity portfolio and found that investing a lump sum immediately beat spreading it over time about 68% of the time.
Missing even a handful of good days is expensive too. J.P. Morgan Asset Management’s 2025 Guide to Retirement reports that missing the 10 best market days over the past 20 years would have cut a portfolio’s annualized return by almost half, and that many of those best days occur close to the worst days — precisely when fear of regret is loudest.
| Regret you fear | Typical behavior | What research says it costs | Counter-move |
|---|---|---|---|
| “I bought right before a crash” | Holding cash indefinitely | Lump sum beat cost averaging ~68% of the time (Vanguard, 1976–2022) | Invest on a fixed date or a short, pre-set schedule |
| “Selling makes the loss real” | Holding losers, selling winners | Winners sold beat losers held by ~3.4 pts the next year (Odean, 1998) | Judge each position as if buying it today |
| “Everyone else got rich and I didn’t” | Chasing hot sectors or funds | Sector-fund investors captured the smallest share of fund returns (Morningstar, 2025) | Cap “conviction” bets at a small, fixed slice |
| “I should have sold before the drop” | Panic selling, then waiting to re-enter | Missing the 10 best days in 20 years nearly halved annualized returns (J.P. Morgan, 2025) | Pre-commit to rebalancing rules, not headlines |
If a lump sum still feels unbearable, a short, fixed schedule — say, three or six equal monthly purchases with dates on your calendar — is a reasonable compromise. The key word is fixed. We dug into the trade-offs in our dollar-cost averaging vs. lump sum myth-buster.
Curious what “waiting for a better entry point” could cost you over 20 years?
Step 3: Apply the “would I buy it today?” test to losers
Terrance Odean’s 1998 study in The Journal of Finance tracked 10,000 discount-brokerage accounts from 1987 to 1993. Investors realized 14.8% of their available gains but only 9.8% of their available losses — selling winners about 1.5 times as readily as losers. Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman, who coined the term “disposition effect” in 1985, pointed to regret aversion as a core driver: selling a loser forces you to admit the original purchase was a mistake.
The fix is a single question for each holding: If I had this position’s current value in cash, would I buy this exact investment today? If the answer is no, the purchase price is irrelevant. In a taxable account, the loss may even be useful — see our analysis of the disposition effect’s year-end tax cost for the math.
Step 4: Write a one-page investment policy
Regret thrives on ambiguity. When there’s no rule, every decision is a fresh referendum on your judgment. A written policy shifts the responsibility from “me, in the moment” to “the plan I made when I was calm.” Keep it to a page:
- Target allocation (e.g., 70% U.S. stocks, 20% international, 10% bonds).
- Contribution schedule (e.g., automatic on the 1st and 15th).
- Rebalancing trigger (e.g., any asset class drifts more than 5 percentage points, checked once a quarter).
- Sell rule (e.g., only when the position fails the Step 3 test or the allocation needs rebalancing).
- “Do nothing” list — events that don’t justify a trade, like a bad week or a scary headline.
Step 5: Automate the decisions you’d otherwise agonize over
Automation is the most reliable regret-aversion tool because it removes the moment of choice entirely. Workplace plans show how powerful this is: Vanguard’s How America Saves 2025 reports that 61% of its defined-contribution plans used automatic enrollment at year-end 2024, and 84% of participants used target-date funds — with 71% of target-date investors holding their entire account in a single fund. Those participants aren’t agonizing over entry points; the system makes the decision for them.
Copy that structure in your own accounts: automatic contributions on a fixed date, automatic dividend reinvestment, and a broadly diversified fund (or a small set of index funds) that doesn’t require constant judgment calls.
Step 6: Separate a small “regret budget” from your core portfolio
Sometimes the regret you’re avoiding is the fear of missing out — the hot stock, the new theme. Telling yourself “never” often backfires. A cleaner approach: carve out a small, fixed slice (many DIY investors use 5% or less) for individual picks or experiments, and keep the remaining 95% on autopilot. If the bet works, you participated. If it doesn’t, the damage is capped.
This also guards against the herd-driven version of regret aversion, where buying what everyone else owns feels safer because a shared mistake hurts less. We explored when following the crowd helps and when it hurts in our contrarian take on herd mentality in investing.
Step 7: Keep a decision journal and review it once a year
Regret is driven by hindsight: once you know the outcome, the “right” choice looks obvious. A decision journal records what you knew at the time. For every trade outside your automated plan, log the date, the reasoning, your confidence level, and what would prove you wrong. Once a year, review it.
You’ll quickly see which decisions were good process with bad luck (no regret needed) and which were impulsive (worth changing). Over time, this rewires the feedback loop from “how do I feel about the result?” to “did I follow a sound process?”
I started keeping a decision journal in a plain spreadsheet a few years back, mostly because the engineer in me wanted actual logs instead of vague memories of “that time I almost bought.” The surprising part wasn’t catching bad trades — it was seeing how many times I’d talked myself out of investing cash for a “better entry” that never came. These days my contributions to index funds and tax-advantaged accounts run on autopilot, and the journal is mostly for the rare discretionary move. Honest result: it didn’t make me a better stock picker, but it made me a far less reactive one.
Common Regret Aversion Investing Mistakes
Treating “doing nothing” as automatically safe. Inaction feels regret-proof because there’s no trade to blame. But leaving money in cash for years is a decision too, and Gilovich and Medvec’s research suggests it’s the kind people regret most over time.
Over-correcting into constant trading. Some investors, burned by the regret of missing a rally, swing the other way and react to everything. Morningstar’s research found that investors in more volatile, specialized strategies like sector funds captured the smallest share of their funds’ returns, while allocation-fund investors captured the most.
Anchoring on your purchase price. Waiting to “get back to even” before selling is regret aversion dressed up as patience. The market doesn’t know what you paid. If you’ve noticed you take bigger risks after gains, our house money effect case study covers the mirror-image bias.
Rewriting the policy during a downturn. Your investment policy is supposed to be written when you’re calm. Changing it in the middle of a sell-off usually means letting today’s fear override yesterday’s judgment. If you must revise it, wait 30 days and make changes only to future contributions.
Assuming a diversified fund removes all regret. It reduces single-stock regret, but you’ll still feel it when the whole market drops. The goal isn’t to feel nothing; it’s to have a plan that doesn’t depend on your feelings.
The Outcome: What Success Looks Like
You won’t stop feeling regret. That’s not the goal, and anyone who promises it is overselling. Success looks like this:
- Cash earmarked for investing gets invested on a known date, not “when things settle down.”
- Each holding passes the “would I buy it today?” test, regardless of purchase price.
- Most of your portfolio runs on automatic contributions and pre-set rebalancing rules.
- Speculative urges are confined to a small, capped slice.
- Your decision journal shows a process you can defend — even in years when the results aren’t pretty.
The behavior gap Morningstar measures — about 1.2 percentage points a year — is one of the few return leaks fully under your control. Closing even part of it, compounded over decades, can matter more than chasing a slightly better fund. Regret aversion investing isn’t a character flaw; it’s a predictable bias. Treat it like any other system bug: identify the trigger, add guardrails, and let automation handle the rest.
Photo by Maxim Hopman on
Unsplash