Disposition Effect Investing: The Year-End Tax Cost of Selling Winners First (Formula + 3 Scenarios)
Odds are you’re about 50% more likely to sell a stock that’s up than one that’s down. That’s not a guess about you in particular. It’s what Terrance Odean found when he went through the trading records of 10,000 discount brokerage accounts. This guide to disposition effect investing mistakes covers the habit of selling winners too early and holding losers too long. You’ll get a simple formula for what it costs you in taxes at year-end, three worked scenarios at different income levels, and a short checklist to use before you place your next sell order.
Late November is when this bias costs the most. Holiday bills arrive, people pull cash from their brokerage accounts, and the tax year closes on December 31. When you need $10,000 and have to choose which position to sell, your gut picks the winner, because selling a winner feels like banking a success and selling a loser feels like admitting a mistake. But the tax code pays you for doing the opposite.
The Problem: Why Disposition Effect Investing Feels So Rational
Economists Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman named the disposition effect in a 1985 Journal of Finance paper, “The Disposition to Sell Winners Too Early and Ride Losers Too Long.” They tied it to prospect theory, the model Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky published in Econometrica in 1979. Prospect theory says we judge outcomes as gains or losses against a reference point, usually the price we paid, and that losses hurt more than equal gains feel good. In Tversky and Kahneman’s 1992 follow-up, losses weighed about 2.25 times as much as gains.
The reference point is what drives the behavior. A stock bought at $60 and now at $100 feels like a $40 win you can lock in. A stock bought at $125 and now at $100 feels like a $25 loss that isn’t real until you sell. So you sell the winner and hold the loser, hoping it gets back to even. If that urge to get back to even sounds familiar, it’s the same pattern behind the house money effect, where investment gains feel like free money. Both biases come from treating your purchase price as if it matters to the market. It doesn’t.
Odean’s 1998 study, “Are Investors Reluctant to Realize Their Losses?” (Journal of Finance, vol. 53, no. 5), measured this directly. He tracked 10,000 accounts at a nationwide discount broker from January 1987 through December 1993 and compared two rates: the proportion of gains realized (PGR) and the proportion of losses realized (PLR).
| Period (Odean, 1998) | Proportion of gains realized | Proportion of losses realized | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Most of the year | 14.8% | 9.8% | Winners are sold about 50% more readily than losers |
| December | 10.8% | 12.8% | Tax deadlines briefly overpower the bias |
The December row is the interesting one. Investors do respond to tax incentives, but only when a deadline forces them to. Mark Grinblatt and Matti Keloharju found the same thing in Finnish data: investors were 36% more likely to sell extreme losers in December than during the rest of the year, and most waited until the last eight trading days. Waiting until the final week of December leaves little room for mistakes, and one of the most common is the wash sale rule trap involving IRAs, which can wipe out a harvested loss for good.
The bias isn’t only a tax problem. Odean found that the winners investors sold went on to beat the losers they kept by about 3.4 percentage points over the following year. Holding losers in the hope of a rebound didn’t pay off on returns either.
The Quick Answer: The Disposition Effect Investing Tax Formula
If you need to raise cash (C) from a taxable brokerage account and you’re choosing between a winner and a loser at the same market price, this formula measures what the choice costs you:
Tax benefit of selling the loser = C × (BasisL ÷ PriceL − 1) × Offset rate
Disposition tax gap = Tax cost of winner + Tax benefit of loser
The gap is the full swing in your tax bill between the two choices. Selling the winner creates a tax bill. Selling the loser creates a deduction. Going with your gut means paying the first and giving up the second.
A few rules from the IRS decide which rates to plug in:
- Gains rate: According to IRS Topic 409, gains on shares held more than one year are long-term and taxed at 0%, 15%, or 20%. Gains on shares held one year or less are short-term and taxed at your ordinary income rate.
- Offset rate: Capital losses first cancel out capital gains. If losses are left over, up to $3,000 a year ($1,500 if married filing separately) can offset ordinary income, and anything beyond that carries forward to future years. If you have no other gains this year, the loss saves you money at your ordinary rate, up to $3,000.
- Surtax: The 3.8% net investment income tax applies above $200,000 of modified AGI for single filers and $250,000 for married couples filing jointly, according to the IRS.
Here are the 2026 long-term capital gains thresholds from IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32. These apply to sales you make before December 31, 2026:
| Long-term rate (2026) | Single, taxable income | Married filing jointly |
|---|---|---|
| 0% | Up to $49,450 | Up to $98,900 |
| 15% | $49,451 – $545,500 | $98,901 – $613,700 |
| 20% | Over $545,500 | Over $613,700 |
Three Scenarios: Raising $10,000 Before December 31
The setup is the same in all three scenarios. You need $10,000 in cash. Position W (the winner) trades at $100 a share, and you paid $60. Position L (the loser) also trades at $100, and you paid $125. You’ve held both for more than a year, and you have no other realized gains in 2026. Selling $10,000 of W realizes a $4,000 gain. Selling $10,000 of L realizes a $2,500 loss, which is under the $3,000 limit, so all of it offsets ordinary income.
| Scenario | Gains rate | Ordinary rate | Tax if you sell W | Tax saved if you sell L | Disposition tax gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Single, ~$85K taxable | 15% | 22% | $600 | $550 | $1,150 |
| 2. Married, ~$80K taxable | 0% | 12% | $0* | $300 | $300 |
| 3. Single, ~$600K taxable | 20% + 3.8% | 35% | $952 | $875 | $1,827 |
*This assumes the $4,000 gain keeps the couple’s taxable income below the $98,900 cap for the 0% rate. These are simplified illustrations that leave out state taxes and phase-outs.
Scenario 1 is the typical case. Following your gut costs $1,150, which is 11.5% of the cash you were trying to raise, just because you picked the winner. If W had been held less than a year, the gain would be short-term and taxed at 22%, making the tax on W $880 and the gap $1,430.
Scenario 2 is the exception. In the 0% long-term bracket, selling the winner costs nothing, so the bias barely matters for taxes. For this couple, the better plan may be to realize gains on purpose while they’re tax-free. We worked through that in our case study on tax gain harvesting at the 0% rate. They could also sell L in a separate transaction for the $300 deduction and get both benefits.
Scenario 3 shows how the gap grows with income. At high incomes, the $3,000 loss deduction is taken at a 35% rate, and the gains rate includes the 3.8% surtax. The choice of which shares to sell is worth more than $1,800 on a $10,000 withdrawal.
Want to see what that $1,150 would grow to if you kept it invested for 20 years?
When Selling the Winner Is Actually Right
The formula doesn’t say you should always sell losers. It says you should know what the choice costs before you make it. Selling the winner is often the better decision in these cases:
- Rebalancing. If one holding has grown to 40% of your portfolio when you meant it to be 20%, trimming it reduces your risk. Paying some tax is a reasonable price for that. The mistake is selling a winner just because it’s up, not selling it because it’s too large a share of your portfolio.
- Your thesis on the loser has gotten worse. If the reasons you bought L no longer hold, sell it for the loss and also don’t buy it back. Selling the loser is the right call in that case, and the tax benefit is extra.
- You’re in the 0% bracket. As Scenario 2 showed, taxes stop mattering much, so decide based on allocation.
- The account is tax-advantaged. Inside an IRA or 401(k), gains and losses don’t create a tax bill or a deduction, so the tax gap is zero. The bias still matters for returns, though, because of the 3.4-point gap Odean found.
I started tracking my own sell decisions a few years ago, mostly because I was curious whether the research described me. I invest in plain index funds across tax-advantaged and taxable accounts and manage it all myself with no advisor, so I expected to be immune. I wasn’t. When I wrote a small script to compare my taxable-account sales against the tax lots I had available, my sales leaned clearly toward high-gain lots, even when I had lots trading below cost in the same fund. The fix that worked was automation, not willpower. Now I decide the lot-selection rule in advance, and the script tells me which lot to sell before I’ve looked at any gain or loss numbers.
A Five-Step Pre-Sell Checklist to Beat the Disposition Effect
- Decide the amount and the reason before you look at gains. Write down why you’re selling, whether it’s to raise cash, rebalance, or exit a position, before you open the cost-basis screen. This keeps the reference-point bias out of the decision.
- Pull up your tax lots, not just the position. IRS Publication 550 lets you choose which specific shares to sell if you identify them to your broker at the time of sale. Most brokers let you set “specific ID” or a default such as “highest cost” or “tax-efficient loss harvesting.” With this, even a fund that’s up overall may have a lot you can sell at a loss.
- Run the formula on your two best candidates. Plug in the numbers. If the gap is $50, it doesn’t matter, so sell whatever fits your allocation. If it’s $1,000 or more, it deserves a second look.
- Check the 61-day wash sale window. A loss is disallowed if you buy substantially identical shares within 30 days before or after the sale, and that includes purchases in your IRA and automatic dividend reinvestments. If you want to keep market exposure, buy a similar fund that isn’t substantially identical. If your losses are small, check whether they’re worth harvesting at all. Our breakdown of whether tax loss harvesting is worth it for small portfolios covers when the paperwork outweighs the savings.
- Don’t wait for the last week of December. Grinblatt and Keloharju found that most loss selling happens in the final eight trading days, when settlement timing, holiday market closures, and rushed decisions all add risk. Make your year-end sales by mid-December so you have time to fix mistakes.
FAQ: Disposition Effect Investing Questions
Is the disposition effect the same as loss aversion?
They’re related but not the same. Loss aversion is the general tendency for losses to feel worse than equal gains. The disposition effect is a specific trading pattern that loss aversion helps cause: selling winners and holding losers. Researchers also point to mental accounting, where each stock is its own account measured against its purchase price, and to regret avoidance as contributing causes.
Do index fund investors suffer from the disposition effect?
Yes, though usually less than people who pick individual stocks. It shows up when you hold several funds or several tax lots of the same fund and have to choose which to sell. Index investors are most exposed when they rebalance or withdraw cash from a taxable account, which is exactly the decision the formula above helps with.
How much can a capital loss reduce my taxes in 2026?
Capital losses first offset capital gains with no limit. After that, up to $3,000 of net loss ($1,500 if married filing separately) can offset ordinary income each year, according to IRS Topic 409, and any unused amount carries forward to future years. How much tax that saves depends on your bracket. A $3,000 deduction saves $660 at a 22% rate.
Photo by Logan Voss on
Unsplash